Should I Homeschool My Child? Some Important Factors

These days, many people are turning to homeschooling for their children’s education. Some have started asking the question, ‘Should I homeschool my child,’ due to problems with school. Others feel they want to spend more time with their children. Still, others think they can do a better job of educating their children than a school can. 

Rebbecca Devitt

I hope you enjoy reading this blog post. If you want to do my course on how to homeschool, click here.

If you’re one of the parents asking these questions, you should know that homeschooling is not as hard as you think. So long as you’re a loving parent who is willing to go out socially with your children and put a little bit of time into helping them with their education, you should do fine.

Parents Agonizing Over the Choice to Homeschool

Making the choice to homeschool is not easy. Home education is considered an alternative choice and is looked upon with some suspicion by many. The stigma is lessening as the myths referring to weird unsocialized homeschoolers dissipate, but homeschooling parents still have to contend with the critics who hold that home education has significant disadvantages.

Initially, my parents never considered home education, but like many homeschooling parents, they were forced to look at home education when school failed to prevent the corruption of their children’s morals by peers.

My parents started our education by putting us in school. Referring to this period, my father said:

‘Everybody else was enrolling their children in school, and of course, as a parent you’re told that your children won’t get a decent education outside of school. Even though our children were crying and not happy at school, we diligently kept sending them back to ‘get an education’. When we decided to homeschool we really beleived our children would be educational drop-kicks – you know, checkout chicks and ditch diggers. However, one became an architect, the other a lawyer, and the other did a year of medical school. We were certainly surprised with the outcome!’

As my parents discovered more and more problems we were having in school, they became desperate to find an alternative. One homeschooling mother in our church suggested we homeschool, at which my mother laughed at the apparently ridiculous suggestion. My mother then replied, ‘I don’t have the educational background to homeschool my children.’ (This is a common objection that is addressed and overcome in this article.)

She then went home and told my father of the conversation. He stopped for a moment, looked at my mother, and said, ‘Well, why shouldn’t we homeschool?’

And that was how my new educational journey began. For me, going from school to homeschool felt like leaving a dark tunnel and stepping out into a warm meadow full of fragrant daisies!

Top Reasons People Choose to Home Educate

Not everyone begins their homeschooling journey the same way my parents did. Many hold different philosophies that clash with traditional educational methods. There are four big categories of reasons parents choose to teach their children at home including:

  • Their child has special needs (or they’re homeschooling for medical reasons)
  • They’re anti-establishment types (a lot of new-age thinkers or hippies)
  • Their child has had a bad experience in school (so they’re home educating for safety reasons like bullying)
  • Religious reasons are the biggest motivation for some (Christians, Muslims, Jews and so on)
Of course, there are  also other reasons a parent might choose home education (peer pressure, homeschoolers have better test scores, and more opportunities to play in nature) and you can read about these in more depth in these two articles:

Why Are More Parents Homeschooling?

The popularity of home education has exploded in the 21st century thanks to more parents realizing the moral (and religious) heritage in our schools is dying. They have given up trying to reform schools and many no longer believe (at least public) schools can pass on good values to their children.

Some of these disillusioned parents are beyond frustrated with schools and, while they don’t have complete confidence in their own ability to teach, think homeschooling couldn’t possibly be any worse than the school system is.

Should you homeschool your child? Is it a good choice? We examine a number of viewpoints and draw a conclusion. #homeschool

Arguments for Home Education

The arguments for homeschooling your child can be either positive or negative (or both!).

That is, you’re going to home educate because there’s something wrong with school (negative) or there’s something about home education you love (positive) and so that’s why you’re homeschooling.

Positive Reasons to Homeschool

Some of you are asking, ‘Should I homeschool my child,’ because you’ve seen other homeschooling families who seem calmer and happier compared to your family. Others might be home educating as this enables them to live certain lifestyles they’re fond of which wouldn’t be possible if their kids were in school (for example, traveling families, also known as world-schooling families).

Some other positive reasons to home educate are:

  1. Your child has special needs, a disability, autism, ADD or ADHD. Schools don’t always have resources to support parents like this.
  2. Most home learners can better interact with a wider variety of age groups.
  3. Homeschools let you spend more time with your children.
  4. At home, parents can better instil their religion with more efficacy than public school will allow.
  5. There are better learning opportunities like entrepreneurship which can start early.
  6. There’s better socialization.
  7. To let children develop better rhetoric and poise in conversation.
  8. Homeschoolers can start college early if they’re ready.
  9. Better family bonding and sibling relationships.
  10. Institute a more personalized education at home as you’re able to choose an educational method and curriculum that suits your family.
  11. Teach children to learn how to learn and learn and to not have to rely on being spoon-fed information as happens in school.
  12. Use the most amazing book in the world as your textbook – the Bible…definitely not allowed in public school.
  13. Give boys more time to be energetic, and spend less time at their desks.
  14. Have more time to do community projects with the family.
  15. Choose when and where you want to study.
  16. Get the school holiday destination you like, without the crowds!
  17. Most children are happier at home.

Homeschool Meme Holiday Crowds

Negative Reasons to Homeschool

Some of you are asking, ‘Should I homeschool my child’ because your children have been bullied – or a school-mate showed your 7-year-old pornography. The negative reasons parents choose to home educate include:

  1. They don’t believe schools are giving their children good moral guidance
  2. Reduced contact with drugs, alcohol, peer pressure, bullying, sexting, sex, pop culture, LGBTIQ+ agenda (great reasons to be homeschooled in high school)
  3. Home schools avoid paying lip-service to political agendas
  4. Schools don’t give teens adequate amounts of rest and this can lead to impaired learning abilities.
  5. Avoid the anxiety that school causes for some children
  6. Skip filler work (AKA busywork)
  7. Avoid insane amounts of unnecessary homework
  8. You don’t have to travel to school every morning and afternoon
Both positive and negative reasons to homeschool are valid, and you shouldn’t be bullied by other people who think you’re ‘sheltering’ your children, just because you can’t stand to see them influenced wrongly or come home in tears because they’re getting smacked over the head every day by a bully.” But, it’s resilience training!” many people cry. To every adult in the world, the treatment many children experience in school is unfair bullying and adults would be liable in a court of law for their behavior. But for a naïve, defenseless kid in the public school playground, it’s called ‘resilience training’. 

“I Just Don’t Think I Have the Patience to Homeschool My Child.”

Many parents question whether they would make good home educators as they don’t believe they have enough patience to homeschool. One home educating mom answered this query concisely when she said:

I planned on public school right up until the moment the teacher told me she didn’t want my son in her class. She suggested I homeschool. For the record, I thought she was crazy! I didn’t have the patience for that. And guess what? I was right, I did not have the patience for it, but I learned, and he learned and we fell in love!

Another mom tackled this question by saying:

I’ve known so many who’s main comment against homeschooling is that they don’t have patience. They say, “Oh, I could never homeschool, I just don’t have the patience for it!” as if homeschool moms are just mystically imbued with the stuff.  

Having true patience is obviously not a requirement, or no one would homeschool!

It is definitely necessary in day to day living with children, but the big picture is more attainable I feel for most.

Actually, I feel it takes more patience from me to deal with outsiders than it does to home educate. Homeschooling is a breeze compared to defending our choices or responding to criticism and ignorance! I don’t think it takes any more patience to homeschool than it does to have kids in general, it’s the naysayers that I need patience for.

Impatience, like many bad traits we possess, can be weeded out of our character by deliberate habit training (I know this from personal experience). Just like people believe they can deal with their stress, anger, or other sins that hold them back, parents can deal with their impatience and flourish as home educators.

Why I Struggle When Someone Asks Me, ‘Should I Homeschool My Child?’

Personally, I really struggle when someone asks me, ‘Should I homeschool my child?’ The ‘old man’ within me wants to say something like, “Yes. Quite frankly, everyone, except a small minority of parents should be homeschooling because public school is a schmuck system designed to socialize, more than to educate and it’s really a socialization system dressed up to be an educational system.”

From experience, I’ve learned this generally gets awful reactions. This is because education is a hot topic. Many people are as devoted to their schools as they are to their country. If anyone tries to attack these institutions, the listener often defends them or goes into their shell and discontinues the conversation.

When I was young and impetuous I didn’t understand this and hence ruined my fair share of relationships due to my overt zeal and preference for homeschooling. But, homeschoolers are often similar to school students in defending their educational background. Many, including me when I was younger, became highly defensive and sensitive of my educational background.

These days when someone asks me whether they should homeschool, I say, “Home education is a great option and you’ll probably love it especially if you stick at it and iron out all the teething problems that initially arise.”

But, the other day, I realized that what I really wanted to say was what Penelope Trunk said:

The biggest lie homeschoolers tell is that home education is not right for everyone. School is totally ineffective. We all know our schools are broken. We are trying to fix them. So the kids in schools are guinea pigs. The bar is very low for how much better life needs to be outside of school for it to be better than school. [Penelope Trunk Education]


While a lot of moms will say, ‘You’ve got to choose what’s right for you,’ and ‘Consider the pros and cons and weigh it all up,’ I am going to just come out and say it. Yes, you should homeschool your child. School’s not hard to beat. I know this because I wrote a book about it with plenty of statistics on all of these issues. I’ve looked at the pros and cons of home education closely and experienced these for myself. I can now say with confidence, homeschooling wins hands-down.

Share your love
Default image
Rebecca Devitt

Most adults don't particularly want to relive their schooling experience on a daily basis. They would gladly move on to a new life devoid of homework and teachers. Very, very few adults will passionately blog about their schooling some 15 years after graduating. This makes Rebecca Devitt somewhat unique. As it happens, she was homeschooled. And she loved it. Still does. And she wishes every kid could get a taste of homeschooling at its very best. Her website How Do I Homeschool, is a springboard for parents to see what a life of homeschooling could be for both them & their children. When she's not blogging Rebecca is still homeschooling her-adult-self by learning Latin, growing weird vegetables and most importantly looking after her two children Luke & Penny. She has a husband Tristan and is a participant at Wollongong Baptist Church. She's also written a book about why parents should homeschool called 'Why on Earth Homeschool'.

Articles: 347

One comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. I like this article a lot. I just recently (last week) started homeschooling my youngest child and in that week I have noticed a major difference in his happiness and learning. The school system is definitely broken, here in Texas at least. I am trying to talk my older son into becoming a home school student also. I would just take him out of the system if I could but I also know better than to push a pre-teen boy into leaving all his social ties. I have also read other articles that back this up and say that if a child is active in the decision he/she will embrace it more easily and it will result in a better schooling atmosphere than being forced into it and there being negative feelings and emotions about the homeschooling. I know my daughter which is my oldest is way too happy with the socialization in her school. Public school works for her because she is a social butterfly and is in all Pre-AP classes so there’s not much busy work for her. I was apprehensive about homeschooling for about a year before actually withdrawing my son. I also had been fed negative information about non-public educated kids but what I was seeing with the treatment of my son by his own teachers was heart wrenching. His english/Language arts teacher told me this year that she “did not have the training to deal with” my son. I have had zero problems out of him. He is very interested in learning and is completing 20+ assignments a day for his class without many reminders from me. He loves telling me all the new things he learned that day. He is unfortunately almost a year behind in school because we had to start his 3rd grade year over again so instead of him getting ahead he is technically just “catching up”. We are definitely happier now not having to deal with his elementary school. He will have to start going to his speech classes but hopefully that wont affect him much. He is amazing in every way and nothing at all like what the teachers this year said he was like. Thank you for spreading information like this for all of us out here who are looking into better ways to raise and teach our children.